The best supper clubs in Wisconsin are the kind of places where you go for the food but stay for the experience. It’s not just about dinner — it’s about that mix of nostalgia, great food, and a laid-back vibe that keeps people coming back.
What makes Wisconsin supper clubs special
Supper clubs aren’t just restaurants — they’re a tradition. They got their start in the mid-1900s as spots where people could settle in for the whole evening. These days, they stick to the classics with signature cocktails, unhurried dinners, and an atmosphere that feels like a step back in time.
When you visit a Wisconsin supper club, you can expect old-fashioned values like scratch-made food, welcoming service, and a relaxed vibe. Most menus feature staples like prime rib, walleye, fried chicken, and the iconic Friday fish fry. Don’t forget the relish tray, a hallmark of the supper club experience, or appetizers like caramelized onion dip to kick off your meal with bold flavors.
Planning your visit to Wisconsin supper clubs
If you’re new to the scene, plan to make a night of it. Most supper clubs open in the late afternoon, and the dining process is unhurried. Start with a cocktail — an old-fashioned is practically mandatory — then move on to an appetizer while soaking in the ambiance. The main course is the highlight, often accompanied by fresh bread, soup, and a salad.
If you’re planning a trip, consider making a weekend of it by pairing your supper club visit with a stop at one of Wisconsin’s breweries. The combination of great food and craft beer makes for a perfect Wisconsin getaway.
Reservations aren’t always required but are often recommended, especially on weekends. Some supper clubs operate seasonally or have limited hours, so be sure to double-check their schedules before heading out.
Supper clubs near Milwaukee
Milwaukee is home to some of Wisconsin’s most iconic supper clubs, each with its own charm and history. Whether you’re craving a perfectly cooked steak, a classic fish fry, or an old-fashioned done right, these spots deliver the full supper club experience.
Five O’Clock Steakhouse
Since 1946, Five O’Clock Steakhouse has been serving up classic supper club vibes with dim lighting, wood paneling and a menu that doesn’t miss. Their bone-in ribeye is the star of the show, and the brandy old-fashioned feels like a must. It’s the perfect spot for date night if you’re looking for a mix of great food and old-school charm.
Jackson Grill
Jackson Grill leans into its title as Milwaukee’s Supper Club with cozy vibes and a focus on great food. Their filet mignon is a favorite, and the intimate setting makes it feel special without trying too hard. This spot is a go-to for a true supper club experience in the city.
The Packing House
Conveniently close to Milwaukee’s airport, this supper club has been a local institution since the 1970s. Their Friday fish fry is worth the drive alone, but you’ll also find plenty of steak and seafood options to keep everyone happy.
Supper clubs in Northern Wisconsin
Northern Wisconsin is known for hearty, comforting meals in cozy settings. Pairing a main course like steak or ribs with a side of cheddar and chive mashed potatoes is a perfect nod to the kind of dishes you’ll enjoy in this region.
Maiden Lake Supper Club
Some places just feel like vacation, and Maiden Lake Supper Club in Mountain, Wisconsin, is one of them. Located on the water’s edge, it’s a spot where great views and even better food come together.
This lakeside supper club is known for its walleye, hand-cut steaks, and classic Old Fashioneds. The dining room’s large windows give you front-row views of Maiden Lake, but honestly, the food might steal the show. It’s the perfect place to slow down, settle in, and enjoy a meal that tastes just as good as it looks.
The Fireside Supper Club
Located near Eagle River, The Fireside combines stunning lake views with a menu filled with supper club staples. Their lake perch and slow-roasted prime rib are customer favorites, and the warm, cabin-like setting is hard to beat.
Norwood Pines Supper Club
When you think of a true Northwoods dining experience, Norwood Pines Supper Club checks every box. Classic supper club fare, cozy ambiance, and a touch of nostalgia all come together here.
Set on the edge of Lake Minocqua, Norwood Pines offers a scenic backdrop to meals that feel just as memorable as the view. Their Friday fish fry is a local favorite, and you can’t go wrong with a perfectly cooked ribeye. The rustic charm and old-school hospitality make it a spot you’ll want to revisit.
Eddie B’s White Spruce Inn
Tucked away in Rhinelander, Eddie B’s White Spruce Inn is the kind of place where hearty plates and friendly service feel like part of the experience.
Known for its woodsy atmosphere and menu full of supper club classics, this spot draws regulars and out-of-towners alike. Their prime rib and ribs have earned a loyal following, and a cocktail at the bar before dinner is practically a tradition. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel at home, even if it’s your first visit.
Supper clubs in Western Wisconsin
Western Wisconsin supper clubs, found in cities like Rice Lake, La Crosse, and Eau Claire, are known for their long-standing history and hearty menus. These spots are great for anyone who enjoys a mix of traditional dishes and a nostalgic dining atmosphere.
Lehman’s Supper Club
In Rice Lake, Lehman’s Supper Club has been serving diners since 1934. Known for their extensive menu, they offer everything from steak and seafood to pasta and lighter fare. Their attention to detail makes every meal feel special.
The Laurel Supper Club
Family-owned and rooted in tradition, The Laurel Supper Club in New Richmond is the kind of place where you walk in hungry and leave feeling like part of the family.
Known for its perfectly cooked steaks and seafood, The Laurel serves up all the classics you expect from a proper supper club. Pair your meal with an Old Fashioned, and you’ve got the full experience. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it a spot worth revisiting, whether you’re a local or just passing through.
Supper clubs in Southern Wisconsin
Southern Wisconsin supper clubs pair stunning views with hearty dishes that are true to the state’s roots. A classic like Wisconsin beer cheese soup fits perfectly with the kinds of meals you’ll find in these iconic spots, delivering bold, cheesy flavors.
Ishnala Supper Club
Set on the shores of Mirror Lake near Wisconsin Dells, Ishnala offers breathtaking views to pair with your meal. Arrive early to enjoy a cocktail on the patio before sampling their menu, which features everything from steaks to seafood.
Rupp’s Downtown
Located in Sheboygan, Rupp’s Downtown is a classic Wisconsin supper club that’s been a favorite for years. Known for its prime rib, seafood, and Friday fish fry, it’s a great spot for anyone craving traditional supper club flavors. The relaxed atmosphere and focus on hearty meals make it worth the drive if you’re in the area or passing through.
The Butterfly Club
In Beloit, The Butterfly Club serves up charm and hospitality alongside their well-loved menu. This family-run supper club has been a favorite for decades, and their homemade desserts are the perfect way to end your meal.
Chissy’s Pub & Grill
In Waldo, Chissy’s Pub & Grill is a family-owned spot that’s been serving the community for over 40 years. Known for its World Famous Old-Fashioned, it also features a menu with various cuisines, including its standout fall-off-the-bone ribs. The comfortable atmosphere and friendly service make it a go-to destination for both locals and visitors.
Schwarz’s Supper Club
In St. Anna, Schwarz’s is a quintessential Wisconsin supper club that’s been serving up incredible meals since 1957. Known for its prime rib and perfectly poured old-fashioned, it’s a must-visit for supper club enthusiasts.
Why the drive is worth it
Wisconsin supper clubs are about more than just food. They’re a big part of what makes the state special — hearty meals, laid-back vibes, and old-school traditions that stick around for a reason. Whether you’re celebrating or just grabbing dinner, you’re in for a great time.
It’s not just about eating when you visit, but also soaking in a piece of Wisconsin’s story. Pick a spot, hit the road and get ready for a night that’s all about good food and good vibes.
Portions of this article originally appeared on Food Drink Life.
Leave a Reply